Handwriting Skills of Ancient Scribes

The Professional Bookhand

In the field of New Testament paleography, the craftsmanship of scribes who produced early manuscripts is evident, particularly in those texts crafted with a professional bookhand. Among these, the Gospel codex known as P4+64+67 stands out for its exceptional calligraphy, use of paragraph markings, double columns, and punctuation. C. H. Roberts, a noted papyrologist, highlighted the structured division of this manuscript into sections, a systematic approach also seen in P75 and in notable fourth-century manuscripts such as Codex Sinaiticus (א) and Codex Vaticanus (B). Roberts pointed out that this structuring system was likely not the invention of the scribe, indicating its broader use beyond the Egyptian region where it was found.

Examples of Professional Manuscripts

Several other manuscripts exemplify the high standards of professional bookhand:

• P30: Known for its clear Biblical Uncial script.
• P39: A beautiful example of early Biblical Uncial.
• P46: Features stichoi notations, indicative of a scribe compensated for their work.
• P66: Likely produced in a scriptorium, reflecting organized, communal copying efforts.
• P75: Crafted by an exceptionally skilled scribe, showcasing meticulous attention to detail.
• P77+P103: Both manuscripts are noted for their refined calligraphy, standard paragraph markings, and punctuation.
• P95: Offers a small portion of the Gospel of John, preserved in high-quality script.
• P104: Celebrated as a gem among early papyri for its outstanding script quality.

These manuscripts, all dated before 300 C.E., provide clear evidence of the advanced skills of ancient scribes. Their ability to produce texts with such precision and beauty speaks to their professional training and the high value placed on the textual transmission of the New Testament writings during this period. Each of these examples, from P4+64+67 to P104, demonstrates that the art of bookhand was not only a technical skill but also a form of high craftsmanship, crucial for preserving some of the earliest Christian documents.

Handwriting Skills of Early Christian Scribes: The Reformed Documentary Hand

Understanding the Reformed Documentary Hand

In the study of early New Testament manuscripts, a significant number were penned in what is termed the “reformed documentary hand.” This style of writing reflects a transition from standard documentary script—typically used for legal and administrative documents—to a more refined style suited for literary works. In their seminal work, The Birth of the Codex, Roberts and Skeat discuss the characteristics of manuscripts from the second century. They note that while these texts may not reach the highest standards of calligraphy seen in other forms, they do exhibit a competent level of writing indicative of skilled scribes. This style, referred to as “reformed documentary,” suggests that the scribes involved were likely professionals who received compensation for their efforts, whether they were Christian or not.

Professional Scribes and Their Role

The transition to using a reformed documentary hand indicates a recognition of the importance of the texts being copied. This style is likely employed by scribes who, accustomed to producing legal documents, adapted their skills to the transcription of literary and religious texts. These scribes might have been hired specifically to create copies of New Testament scriptures, either for individual believers or for Christian communities. The professional background of these scribes suggests that they were capable of adjusting their handwriting to suit the specific demands of different manuscript types—shifting from purely administrative tasks to the careful copying of sacred texts.

Examples of New Testament Manuscripts in Reformed Documentary Hand

Among the papyri dating to before 300 C.E., at least fifteen New Testament manuscripts are identified as written in the reformed documentary hand. These include:

• P1: Known for its early script style that aligns with the reformed documentary characteristics.
• P30, P32, P35, P38: Each of these papyri shows the distinct handwriting features typical of this style.
• P45: One of the more famous papyri, showcasing a clear example of reformed documentary handwriting.
• P52: Often cited as one of the oldest New Testament fragments, demonstrating early Christian scribal practices.
• P69, P87, P90, P100, P102, P108, P109, P110: These manuscripts collectively exemplify the widespread adoption of the reformed documentary style among early Christian scribes.

These manuscripts highlight the adaptability of scribes who bridged their traditional documentary skills with the needs of emerging Christian literary forms. The use of reformed documentary hand in these texts not only facilitated the spread of Christian writings but also ensured a certain level of uniformity and readability across various copies, reflecting both the practical and doctrinal considerations of early Christian communities.

Handwriting Skills of Early Christian Scribes: The Documentary Hand

Characteristics of Documentary Handwriting

In the realm of early Christian manuscripts, many of the texts were not products of a formal book trade but rather the efforts of community members with practical writing experience. These individuals, often businessmen and minor officials, were adept at creating documents and applied these skills to manuscript production. The documentary hand used by these scribes differs significantly from the more refined scripts produced by professional scribes. One notable feature is the lack of bilinearity—the consistent alignment of the tops and bottoms of letters across a line. Instead, documentary texts typically show a larger initial letter at the beginning of each line or section, a practice evident in manuscripts such as P. Bremer 5 from 117 C.E.

This style of script also features sporadic punctuation and frequent use of numerical abbreviations, common in practical document writing. Furthermore, spaces between words or groups of words are more prevalent, mirroring the style found in legal contracts. This spacing was uncommon in literary texts, which tended to favor a more continuous script. Examples of New Testament texts written in documentary style include Revelation manuscripts P47 and P98, which exhibit these characteristic features.

The Role of Churchmen and Women in Manuscript Production

The bulk of early New Testament manuscripts fall into the categories of documentary or reformed documentary styles. These manuscripts were often produced by church members—possibly church lectors—who were skilled in document writing. These scribes applied their practical skills to the task of copying scriptures, likely for specific patrons who commissioned their services or for use within their congregations.

Historian Gamble suggests that many of these scribes were church lectors, responsible for maintaining and reproducing copies of the scriptures. Their role extended beyond mere copying; they also prepared texts for public reading, ensuring that the scriptures were accessible and understandable to the congregation. This dual role of copying and presenting the text highlights the critical function these individuals played in the early Christian community.

Documentary New Testament Manuscripts

According to research, a significant portion of the early New Testament papyri can be classified as “documentary.” This includes manuscripts like P5, P13, P15+P16, P17, P20, P23, P27, P28, P29, P37, P47, P48, P49+65, P50, P53, P70, P80, P91, P92, P101, P106, P107, P108, P111, P113, and P114. Each of these manuscripts bears the hallmarks of documentary handwriting, reflecting the practical origins of their creation.

These manuscripts collectively demonstrate how early Christian communities leveraged the existing skills of their members to create enduring religious texts. The use of a documentary hand not only facilitated the spread of Christian teachings but also ensured that the scriptures were recorded in a manner that was both practical and familiar to those within the community. This approach helped preserve the accuracy and readability of the scriptures during a formative period in Christian history.

Handwriting Skills of the Scribes: Understanding the Common Hand

Differentiating Documentary and Common Hands

In the study of ancient manuscripts, particularly those related to the New Testament, distinguishing between a poorly executed documentary hand and a common hand can be challenging. While both may appear similar, the common hand typically represents the work of someone who may not have been formally trained in Greek writing. This style often looks more rudimentary and less structured than even a low-quality documentary script.

Examples of the Common Hand in New Testament Papyri

• P10: This manuscript serves as a classic example of the common hand, showing traits that suggest it was penned by someone still learning to write Greek effectively.
• P9: Containing a portion of 1 John, this papyrus is also clearly written in a common hand, reflecting a basic level of script competency.
• P78: An amulet written in a common hand, illustrating that this less formal writing style was not confined to biblical texts but extended to other types of written artifacts as well.

Common Hand in Revelation Manuscripts

Interestingly, a significant number of manuscripts containing the Book of Revelation exhibit characteristics of the common hand:

• P18 and P24: Both of these papyri are examples where the common hand is evident, showcasing a more rudimentary style of Greek script.
• P98: This manuscript is particularly noted for its common hand, displaying a very basic level of script which further emphasizes the amateurish qualities of the writer.

This prevalence of the common hand in Revelation manuscripts might indicate that these texts were not widely read in early Christian churches or that they were not often copied by trained scribes. The reasons for this could be many, including the possible private use of these texts or their less formal circulation among groups not directly connected to the main ecclesiastical authorities.

The Significance of the Common Hand

The appearance of the common hand in significant religious texts like Revelation suggests a few key points about early Christian text transmission:

1. Accessibility: Texts were accessible to a broad audience, including those who were not professionally trained scribes but who still engaged in the copying of texts.
2. Variety of Manuscript Production: There was a variety of contexts in which manuscripts were produced, not solely through professional scribe services but also by individuals with basic writing skills.
3. Archaeological Implications: The discovery of texts in common hand may point to differing practices of text usage and preservation, possibly indicating private ownership or use in less formal religious settings.

These insights help paint a broader picture of the early Christian world, highlighting the diversity of its textual practices and the wide range of individuals involved in the creation and propagation of biblical manuscripts.

Overview of Early Christian Handwriting Styles for Dating Manuscripts

In the study of New Testament paleography, which examines ancient handwriting, four main styles from the early Christian period are particularly notable. These are Roman Uncial, Biblical Uncial, Decorated Rounded Uncial, and Severe (or Slanted) style. Each style represents a unique approach to script used in early Christian manuscripts.

Characteristics and Chronology of Styles

1. Roman Uncial: This style is characterized by its rounded, clear letters that are easy to read, often used in official documents and early Christian texts.
2. Biblical Uncial: Similar to Roman Uncial but tailored for religious texts, this script features slightly more elongated letters, making it distinctive.
3. Decorated Rounded Uncial: This style enhances the basic uncial form with additional decorative elements, making the script both beautiful and functional for more luxurious manuscripts.
4. Severe (or Slanted) Style: Known for its more angular and tilted characters, this style presents a more dramatic and dynamic form of writing.

While these styles are distinct, they are not always completely separate from each other. The evolution of these handwriting styles involved a significant amount of overlap and integration, where features from one style would blend into others, creating a ‘crossbreeding’ effect in their development. Identifying the exact origin of each style is challenging due to this intermixing.

The popularity and use of each style followed a chronological pattern, with each emerging, becoming popular, and eventually fading out of common use at different times throughout the early Christian era. This timeline helps scholars trace the development and use of the styles in historical and religious manuscripts.

The Roman Uncial in Early Christian Manuscripts

Emergence and Characteristics of Roman Uncial

The Roman Uncial style of handwriting, an important script in the study of paleography related to New Testament textual criticism, is believed to have emerged shortly after the end of the Ptolemaic period, around 30 B.C.E. This style continued to be prevalent through the first two to three centuries of the Christian era. Roman Uncial is characterized by its round and smooth letterforms, which show a distinct evolution from the sharper and more compact script of the preceding Ptolemaic period. This script is larger and includes decorative serifs on several, but not all, letters, distinguishing it from other contemporary styles.

Comparison with Biblical Uncial

While Roman Uncial served as a foundational script for later developments, it is often considered a precursor to Biblical Uncial. Although some paleographers use the terms interchangeably, there are notable differences between these two styles. Biblical Uncial, unlike its predecessor, typically features minimal to no decoration and is known for its shading, which results from the deliberate alternation of thick and thin pen-strokes. This shading is closely related to the angle at which the pen is held against the paper, a technique that adds depth and texture to the script.

Notable Manuscripts and Observations

A prominent example of Roman Uncial can be seen in the manuscript P46, which dates from around 100-150 C.E. This manuscript is significant for its early style and well-formed characters, typical of the Roman period. Kenyon, the editor of the editio princeps of P46, remarked on the quality and formation of the letters, noting their classical Roman characteristics. This observation underscores the manuscript’s value in studying the transition and refinement of writing styles in early Christian texts.

Evolution of the Biblical Uncial Script

The Development of Biblical Uncial

The term “Biblical Uncial” or “Biblical Majuscule” refers to a distinct handwriting style characterized by large, separate letters, which do not connect in the flowing manner seen in cursive or ligature scripts. This style was initially identified by Grenfell and Hunt in their examination of biblical manuscripts but was later recognized in various other texts as well. Notably, this script maintains a bilinear format where text aligns along imaginary upper and lower lines. In Biblical Uncial, most letters fit into uniform squares, maintaining consistent vertical heights except for a few like gamma, rho, phi, and psi. The script is marked by a deliberate contrast between thick vertical strokes and thinner horizontal ones, with right-angled and perfectly circular strokes, devoid of any connecting ligatures or ornamental serifs.

Historical Context and Emergence

The first instances of what would become known as Biblical Uncial appeared in the first century C.E. The style is thought to have originated shortly after the Herculaneum manuscript, P. Herculaneum 1457, identified by Domenico Bassi in 1914 as showing early characteristics of this script. This manuscript, predating the catastrophic eruption of 79 C.E., is among the earliest examples demonstrating the transition toward what would be fully realized as Biblical Uncial.

Significant Manuscripts and Chronological Development

An important document that showcases an early form of Biblical Uncial is P. London II 141, dated to 88 C.E. This manuscript is particularly valued for its resemblance to early vellum manuscripts of a similar style. By the second century, examples such as P. Hawara 24–28 and P. Tebtunis II 265 further illustrate the evolving script. P. Oxyrhynchus 20, another key manuscript from this period, features the Iliad on its recto in a distinct uncial script, demonstrating the durability and continued use of such luxurious manuscripts.

G. Cavallo, in his work “Ricerche sulla Maiuscola Biblica,” argues that the Biblical Uncial style was definitively shaped in the mid to late second century C.E. He bases this on several well-dated manuscripts from this period, including P. Oxyrhynchus 661, dated confidently to the second half of the second century. This manuscript, along with others like P. Oxyrhynchus 678 and P. Oxyrhynchus 2356, helps establish a clearer timeline for the popularity and standardization of the Biblical Uncial style.

The Role of Biblical Uncial in Early Christian Texts

As the style matured, it became prevalent in early Christian texts. Manuscripts such as P4+64+67, P30, and P70, among others, were composed in Biblical Uncial, demonstrating its widespread adoption for religious writings. The consistency and clarity of this script made it ideal for the transcription of important texts, facilitating the dissemination of Christian doctrines and scriptures.

The Biblical Uncial style, with its distinctive aesthetic and functional qualities, played a crucial role in the preservation and interpretation of early Christian manuscripts. Its development from the first century onward highlights its significance in the broader context of script evolution in ancient literary cultures.

The Decorated Rounded Uncial in Paleography

Defining the Decorated Rounded Uncial

The Decorated Rounded Uncial, also known as the Zierstil, identified by paleographers like Schubart, is a distinct handwriting style prevalent from the last century of the Ptolemaic period (first century B.C.E.) to potentially as late as the early third century C.E. This style is characterized by its use of large uncial letters where each vertical stroke is often finished with a serif or a decorated roundel. E. G. Turner extended its timeline, suggesting that these particular features were part of several styles spanning from the second century B.C.E. to the second century C.E., indicating a broader use and evolution of this script.

Characteristics and Manuscript Examples

Manuscripts featuring the Decorated Rounded Uncial are notably conspicuous due to their aesthetic embellishments and size of the letters. These characteristics can be seen in a range of dated manuscripts from 100 B.C.E. to 150 C.E., exhibiting variations from Formal Round to Informal Round styles. The following are some key examples:

1. P. Rylands 586 + P. Oxyrhynchus 802 (Deed of Loan, 99 B.C.E.) – Represents a later Ptolemaic decorated style.
2. P. Fouad 266 (Septuagint, mid-first century B.C.E.) – A seminal biblical text with distinctive Ptolemaic cursive notes.
3. Greek Minor Scroll Prophets from Nahal Hever, 8HevXIIgr (50 B.C.E. to 50 C.E.) and 7Q1 (Exodus, 100 B.C.E.) – Both showcase early forms of this decorated style.
4. Several manuscripts from Herculaneum (first century B.C.E.) – These are notably from Philodemus’s library, giving them a pre-79 C.E. dating, crucially before the destruction of Herculaneum.
5. P. Murabba‘at 108 (early first century C.E.) and P. Oxyrhynchus 1453 (Oath of Temple Lamplighters, 30–29 B.C.E.) – Both are significant for their clear use of Zierstil.
6. P. London II.354 (Petition to Caius Turranius, 7–4 B.C.E.) – An informal but slightly decorated round hand.

Analysis and Implications

These examples illustrate the widespread application and the aesthetic evolution of the Decorated Rounded Uncial from formal literary manuscripts to more informal documentary uses. Notably, the more formal versions of this handwriting style provided good comparisons for biblical manuscripts written in a bookhand, while the informal versions were often used in reformed documentary and documentary hands.

The continued discovery and dating of these manuscripts affirm the presence and stylistic continuity of the Decorated Rounded Uncial style well into the second century C.E. and, as suggested by Turner, potentially into the third century. This assertion is based on the appearance of similar serifs and decorations in manuscripts like P. Oxyrhynchus 3093, dated 217 C.E., showcasing how elements of the Decorated Rounded style persisted over time.

Contributions to New Testament Manuscripts

In New Testament textual criticism, manuscripts such as P32, P66, P90, and P104, which display the Decorated Rounded style, are critical for understanding the textual and visual context of the early Christian scriptures. These manuscripts are generally dated to the period before 150 C.E., reflecting the style’s significance in the early transmission of Christian texts.

This exploration of the Decorated Rounded Uncial not only highlights its aesthetic appeal but also its functional role in the broader historical and cultural manuscript traditions of the early Christian era.

The Severe Style in Ancient Greek Handwriting

Evolution of the Severe Style

During the Ptolemaic and Roman periods, the standard form of Greek handwriting was predominantly upright. However, as time progressed, a shift occurred where scribes began to slant their letters to the right. This change in direction emphasized the angularity of the letters and altered the appearance of curves, making them resemble ellipses rather than perfect circles. This style, characterized by a mix of narrow and broad letters, is known as the Severe style, termed “Strenge Stil” by Schubart and “Formal Mixed” by Turner. Turner noted that before the Hadrian era (117–138 C.E.), there was little emphasis on contrasting broad and narrow letters within documents. Contrarily, G. Cavallo highlighted that manuscripts exhibiting this variance in letter width were present in Herculaneum well before the second century, indicating an earlier origin for this stylistic feature.

Manuscript Examples Demonstrating the Severe Style

Several manuscripts from the second to the fourth century C.E., with well-established dates, showcase the Severe style:

1. P. Giss. 3 (117 C.E.): This document celebrates Emperor Hadrian’s accession and features one of the earliest examples of the broad, slanting handwriting style that gained popularity in subsequent periods.
2. P. Michigan 3 (late second century C.E.): Dated firmly to the latter half of the second century due to a documentary text on the verso dated 190 C.E.
3. P. Oxyrhynchus 2341 (202 C.E.): A record of legal proceedings confirming the date.
4. P. Florentine II. 108 (circa 200 C.E.): Part of the Heroninos archive, this manuscript of Homer’s Iliad III is dated approximately 50 years prior to the archive’s latest documents around 260 C.E.
5. P. Rylands I. 57 (circa 200 C.E.): Contains Demosthenes’ “De Corona,” also part of the Heroninos archive.
6. P. Florentine II. 259 (circa 260 C.E.): A letter from the same archive, written in a style common to professional literary hands of that era.
7. P. Oxyrhynchus 2098 (first half of the third century C.E.): Features a text from Herodotus on the recto, with a land survey on the verso from the reign of Gallienus, suggesting a composition date for the literary text around 200–225 C.E.
8. P. Oxyrhynchus 1016 (early to mid-third century C.E.): This manuscript’s dating is challenging but is estimated to be no later than 240–250 C.E., based on various interpretations of the regnal years mentioned in associated documents.
9. P. Oxyrhynchus 223 (early third century C.E.): Written on the verso of a document dated 186 C.E., it contains a text from Homer’s Iliad.
10. P. Herm. Rees 5 (circa 325 C.E.): Addressed to a government official known from the John Rylands archives to be active in the early 320s C.E.

Connection to New Testament Manuscripts

The Severe style is not only evident in classical and documentary texts but also in early Christian manuscripts. Notable New Testament papyri such as P13, P45, P48, P49, P110, and P115 exhibit this distinctive slanted handwriting, linking this stylistic evolution to the broader context of early Christian literature. This connection underscores the stylistic diversity present in early Christian texts and highlights the adaptability of script styles like the Severe style in various literary and documentary contexts across centuries.

About the Author

SCROLL THROUGH THE DIFFERENT CATEGORIES BELOW

BIBLE TRANSLATION AND TEXTUAL CRITICISM

BIBLE TRANSLATION AND TEXTUAL CRITICISM

BIBLICAL STUDIES / BIBLE BACKGROUND / HISTORY OF THE BIBLE/ INTERPRETATION

EARLY CHRISTIANITY

HISTORY OF CHRISTIANITY

CHRISTIAN APOLOGETIC EVANGELISM

TECHNOLOGY AND THE CHRISTIAN

CHRISTIAN THEOLOGY

CHRISTIAN DEVOTIONALS

CHRISTIAN FICTION