The Pool of Bethesda, situated just north of the Temple Mount in Jerusalem, provides one of the most remarkable archaeological confirmations of the historical accuracy of the Gospel of John. The site, long dismissed by critics as a theological construct or allegorical symbol within John’s Gospel, has been unearthed and verified through extensive excavations. These discoveries demonstrate the precision of the apostolic testimony and affirm the reliability of the biblical record in every detail.

Historical and Biblical Context

In the Gospel of John, chapter 5, verses 1–9, we read of a pool in Jerusalem near the Sheep Gate, called in Hebrew “Bethesda,” having five colonnades. At this pool lay a multitude of the sick, blind, lame, and paralyzed, waiting for the stirring of the water. It was at this very location that Jesus performed one of His most significant miracles, healing a man who had been disabled for thirty-eight years. The narrative is direct, topographically specific, and historically grounded. John’s precision—mentioning the pool’s location, its Hebrew name, and its architectural design—demanded a corresponding reality.

For centuries, however, critics of Scripture, especially those influenced by the rationalist skepticism of the 19th century, argued that such a pool could not have existed. They claimed that the description of “five colonnades” was purely symbolic—perhaps representing the five books of Moses or the grace of God extended through the Law. Such interpretations reflected the allegorical and non-historical approach of liberal theology, which sought to strip the Gospel of its concrete historicity. Yet, as archaeology has repeatedly shown, the biblical record is not allegorical but factual.

The Rediscovery of Bethesda

In the 19th century, archaeological investigations in Jerusalem began to uncover the physical remains of the pool described by John. The site lies beneath and around the area of the modern St. Anne’s Church, located just north of the Temple Mount and near the present-day Lions’ Gate. Excavations led by Conrad Schick and others between the late 19th and mid-20th centuries revealed two large adjoining reservoirs separated by a central partition, surrounded by four colonnades, with a fifth running across the middle—precisely as described in the Gospel of John.

The pools date to the period between the late Hasmonean and early Herodian eras (approximately the 1st century B.C.E. through the 1st century C.E.), fitting perfectly with the timeframe of Jesus’ ministry. The structure measured roughly 165 by 200 feet and reached a depth of about 49 feet in certain sections. The layout was both practical and ceremonial, serving as a water reservoir system for Jerusalem and likely functioning also as a ritual purification site, or mikveh, for the Jewish population. The association of the site with healing practices further corresponds with later evidence of pagan and Roman healing shrines built atop or around the same area after the destruction of Jerusalem in 70 C.E.

The Architectural and Cultural Setting

Archaeologists identified the lower pool as the original reservoir and the upper pool as an expansion constructed under Herod the Great or his successors. The pools were supplied with water from nearby sources and channels, forming part of Jerusalem’s broader water management system. The discovery of steps descending into the pool and remnants of surrounding porticoes confirmed that it had been a place frequented by the public—both for practical and religious purposes.

The Greek name “Bethesda” (Beth hesda) means “house of mercy” or “house of grace.” This name harmonizes perfectly with the narrative of John 5, where Jehovah’s mercy through His Son was manifested in healing. Later, after the Roman conquest, the area was reconfigured, and pagan structures—such as a shrine dedicated to Asclepius, the Greek god of healing—were constructed over the ancient pools. This overlay of pagan worship upon a biblical site mirrors the broader pattern of Roman syncretism and underscores the contrast between divine truth and human superstition.

Refuting Allegorical Interpretations

Before the excavations, liberal scholars often dismissed John’s Gospel as a late theological reflection lacking historical foundation. They argued that John’s detailed knowledge of Jerusalem’s geography was a product of imagination or post-Temple nostalgia. Yet, the Pool of Bethesda stands as tangible refutation. The precision of John’s description—the location near the Sheep Gate, the presence of five colonnades, and the pool’s specific designation—all converge to demonstrate firsthand knowledge of pre-70 C.E. Jerusalem.

Such archaeological confirmation decisively overturns the notion that John’s Gospel is “spiritualized history.” Instead, it reveals that the apostle’s account was written by someone intimately familiar with the city’s topography before its destruction. This discovery has led even secular scholars to admit that John’s Gospel, far from being the latest and least historical, preserves authentic eyewitness testimony of first-century Jerusalem.

The Pool’s Religious Function and Healing Associations

The narrative of John 5 describes an angel stirring the waters, after which the first to enter was healed of disease. While this particular textual note is absent from the earliest manuscripts (as shown by critical textual evidence), the popular belief in the healing properties of the pool reflects the expectations of that period. Such associations were common in the Second Temple era, when pools, springs, and water reservoirs were often imbued with religious or healing significance.

In the case of Bethesda, it is likely that the periodic movement of the water—caused by intermittent inflow from subterranean springs—was interpreted by the populace as a divine or angelic sign. Jesus’ healing of the paralytic man, however, did not depend upon the supposed mystical powers of the water but upon His own divine authority. In contrast to human superstition, Christ’s word alone accomplished what no ritual or physical medium could achieve. This miracle thus demonstrated His identity as the Son of God and the source of true spiritual and physical restoration.

Theological Implications and the Authority of Scripture

The Pool of Bethesda stands not merely as a site of archaeological interest but as a witness to the inerrancy of Scripture. Every stone unearthed at St. Anne’s confirms that the Gospel of John is not a theological invention but a factual account grounded in real places, people, and events. The discovery affirms that the writer of the Fourth Gospel possessed firsthand knowledge of Jerusalem’s geography, which would have been nearly impossible for a late, second-century author to reconstruct after the Roman destruction of the city.

Furthermore, the pool illustrates the broader pattern of biblical archaeology consistently validating Scripture against the claims of skeptics. From the discovery of the House of David inscription to the confirmation of Pontius Pilate’s existence, the stones of the earth continually cry out in testimony that the Bible is trustworthy and divinely inspired. Archaeology does not create faith, but it removes the false grounds of unbelief by demonstrating the Bible’s historical veracity.

The Continuity of the Site

Today, visitors to Jerusalem can view the remains of the Pool of Bethesda adjacent to St. Anne’s Church, a Crusader-era structure built to commemorate the birthplace of Mary, the mother of Jesus. Beneath and around the church lie the stratified remains of the original pools, later Roman shrines, and Byzantine constructions. The site serves as a visual narrative of Jerusalem’s layered history—from Jewish purification rites to Roman paganism, from Christian commemoration to modern archaeological study.

The continued presence of the site testifies to the enduring truth of God’s Word. While empires have risen and fallen, and while human philosophies have shifted with the tides of skepticism, the biblical account remains unshaken. The Pool of Bethesda, once a place of human infirmity and false hope, became the stage upon which Jesus revealed His divine power to heal and restore. In doing so, He demonstrated that true grace and mercy are found not in the traditions of men, but in the Person and Word of the Son of God.

The Pool of Bethesda as a Testament to Biblical Accuracy

The excavation of the Pool of Bethesda is one of many examples where archaeological discovery has silenced centuries of doubt. What was once mocked as allegory is now recognized as precise topographical description. The discovery has forced even secular archaeologists to concede that John’s Gospel preserves authentic memories of pre-destruction Jerusalem. It is a vindication not only of John’s authorship but of the divine inspiration of Scripture itself.

The pool’s existence, layout, and historical context verify that the Gospel of John is both theologically profound and historically reliable. The healing that occurred there was not a metaphor, but a real event recorded by an eyewitness under the inspiration of the Holy Spirit. Through this and countless other discoveries, Jehovah’s Word is vindicated as the unerring record of His dealings with mankind.

You May Also Enjoy

Inscription of Lysanias (Tetrarch of Abilene) – Abila near Damascus — c. 14–29 C.E.

About the Author

CLICK LINKED IMAGE TO VISIT ONLINE STORE

CLICK TO SCROLL THROUGH OUR BOOKS