Why Did God Confront Cain, and What Does It Teach About Sin and Responsibility?

Please Support the Bible Translation Work of the Updated American Standard Version (UASV)

$5.00

Christian Living Based on Genesis 4:6–7

“Then Jehovah said to Cain, ‘Why are you angry? And why is your face gloomy? If you do well, will you not be accepted? But if you do not do well, sin is lurking at the door; and its desire is for you, but you must master it.'” — Genesis 4:6–7

The conversation recorded in Genesis 4:6–7 is one of the earliest and most revealing interactions between God and man after the fall. These verses come in the context of Cain and Abel, the sons of Adam and Eve, who each brought offerings to Jehovah. Abel’s offering was accepted because it was brought in faith and obedience (Hebrews 11:4), while Cain’s was rejected due to a heart that was not right before God.

Instead of repenting or seeking correction, Cain became angry. His face fell—a Hebrew expression denoting both discouragement and defiance. But rather than immediately punishing Cain, Jehovah confronts him with a question and a warning. In divine mercy, God extends to Cain the opportunity to turn from his error. These verses reveal much about God’s justice, His patience, and His call for moral accountability.

Genesis 4:6–7 lays the theological groundwork for understanding sin not just as action, but as a force with intent and desire—a power that must be ruled over. God appeals to Cain’s conscience, holds him responsible for his attitude, and charges him to choose what is right. The message remains relevant for every believer today: when sin is crouching at the door, we must not yield to it—we must overcome it by doing what is good in the eyes of Jehovah.

This devotional will explore the context of Cain’s offering, God’s probing questions, the nature of sin’s desire, and the call to overcome temptation through obedience and self-discipline.

“Why Are You Angry? And Why Is Your Face Gloomy?” — God’s Confrontation of the Heart

Jehovah’s first response to Cain is not condemnation but confrontation. He asks, “Why are you angry? And why is your face gloomy?” These questions are not asked out of ignorance—God knows all things. They are designed to reveal Cain’s heart and prompt self-examination.

Cain’s anger is not righteous indignation. It is the resentment of one who has been corrected. Instead of asking what was wrong with his offering or seeking to amend his approach, Cain internalized bitterness. His fallen face (panim naphlu, literally, “face fallen”) signifies shame, defiance, and unresolved frustration.

Jehovah’s gentle question implies: You have no reason to be angry if your intentions were pure. If there is a problem, it can be corrected. The issue is not with the standard but with Cain’s unwillingness to meet it.

This is the first recorded instance of someone being angry with God for holding them to a moral standard. It exemplifies the rebellion that emerged from the fall—man’s tendency to justify himself, shift blame, and resent divine correction. Yet even here, God’s approach is restorative, not vindictive.

Believers today must also heed this. When God’s Word corrects us, when our conscience is pricked, when spiritual conviction comes, we must not respond with self-pity or rage. We must ask ourselves: Why am I angry? Is it because I’ve been confronted with truth that contradicts my pride? Jehovah’s questions remain His way of calling the sinner to repentance and restoration.

“If You Do Well, Will You Not Be Accepted?” — The Conditional Nature of Divine Favor

Jehovah then offers Cain a conditional promise: “If you do well, will you not be accepted?” The word for “accepted” (שְׂאֵת, se’eth) can mean lifted up—possibly a reference to Cain’s fallen face. God is essentially saying, If you choose what is right, there is restoration. Your countenance can be lifted, your offering made acceptable.

This is a principle found throughout Scripture: Jehovah rewards obedience and holds each person responsible for their moral choices. Divine favor is not arbitrary. Cain was not rejected without cause. His offering lacked faith, sincerity, and obedience (cf. 1 John 3:12). Abel brought from the firstborn of his flock, honoring God with what was most valuable. Cain’s offering, described simply as “some of the fruits,” lacked the devotion and heart that God desires.

Yet here, God assures Cain that the door to acceptance remains open. If he repents and does well, he too can be approved. This principle is echoed later in Ezekiel 18:21–22, where God declares that the wicked who repents will live, and none of his transgressions will be remembered.

This verse refutes any deterministic view of human morality. Cain was not doomed to rejection. He had a choice. He was being warned and encouraged. The same is true today. Those who humble themselves and walk in righteousness will be accepted by God—not on the basis of merit but through faithful obedience to His commands.

“But If You Do Not Do Well…” — The Warning of Sin’s Predatory Nature

Having offered a way back, Jehovah issues a solemn warning: “But if you do not do well, sin is lurking at the door.” Here, sin is personified—as a beast lying in wait, ready to pounce. The Hebrew term translated “lurking” (רֹבֵץ, rovets) often refers to a crouching animal, poised to attack. Sin is not merely an action—it is a force, a desire, a corrupt impulse that waits to seize those who entertain it.

The imagery is vivid: sin is outside the door, not yet inside. Cain had not yet murdered Abel. But if he did not master his emotions and choose righteousness, the beast would enter. This reflects James 1:14–15: “But each one is tempted when he is carried away and enticed by his own lust. Then when lust has conceived, it gives birth to sin; and sin, when it has run its course, brings forth death.”

The sin was not yet actualized, but it was crouching—near, dangerous, and ready to dominate if left unchecked.

This imagery also underscores personal responsibility. Sin seeks to dominate, but it does not possess unless invited. The door must be opened from within. No one is forced into rebellion. Even after the fall, God holds mankind accountable to resist sin, warning that its influence is potent but not irresistible.

Believers today must recognize sin’s subtlety and proximity. It crouches at the door—in thoughts, in desires, in attitudes—waiting for a crack through which to enter. But God gives strength to those who submit to Him. “Resist the devil and he will flee from you” (James 4:7).

“Its Desire Is for You, But You Must Master It” — The Call to Rule Over Sin

Jehovah ends His exhortation with this stark truth: “Its desire is for you, but you must master it.” The structure echoes Genesis 3:16, where God tells Eve that her desire would be for her husband, but he would rule over her. The Hebrew phrase indicates not mutual attraction but conflict of will—the desire to control or assert authority.

Here, sin is said to “desire” Cain—not in affection but in intent to dominate. The same desire that led Satan to deceive and Eve to reach for forbidden knowledge now seeks to control Cain’s heart. But God commands him: “You must master it.” The imperative shows that Cain is morally responsible. He cannot claim ignorance or helplessness.

Mastering sin requires conscious resistance, repentance, and submission to God. In the New Testament, Paul speaks of “putting to death the deeds of the body” (Romans 8:13) and of making no provision for the flesh (Romans 13:14). Victory over sin is not achieved through self-effort alone but through walking in the Spirit and remaining in the truth (Galatians 5:16–17; John 8:31–32).

Cain, tragically, did not heed the warning. He opened the door, allowed sin to dominate, and committed the first murder. But the fault was his, not God’s. He had been warned, exhorted, and offered a path of restoration.

Application: Heeding God’s Voice in the Battle with Sin

The timeless truth of Genesis 4:6–7 applies directly to every believer:

Examine Your Heart When Corrected: When convicted by God’s Word, do not respond in anger. Ask yourself: Why am I angry? Let God’s correction lead to repentance, not rebellion.
Remember God’s Acceptance Is Conditional on Obedience: We are accepted when we respond in faith and do what is right. God desires sincerity, not empty ritual (1 Samuel 15:22).
Recognize the Danger of Crouching Sin: Sin waits for opportunity. Do not entertain it. Cut it off while it is still at the door (Matthew 5:29–30).
Take Responsibility to Master It: God has not left us helpless. Through His Word, His Spirit, and the body of Christ, we can resist temptation and walk in righteousness (1 Corinthians 10:13).
Walk in the Spirit Daily: Mastery over sin is not a one-time battle. It is a daily fight of faith (1 Timothy 6:12), requiring vigilance and constant submission to God’s will.

Conclusion: Choose What Is Right While the Door Is Closed

Genesis 4:6–7 is not just the prelude to Cain’s sin—it is a divine appeal to the conscience of every man. God’s voice reaches out to the sinner, probing the heart, offering restoration, warning of danger, and calling to overcome. Cain’s failure is not inevitable—it is a tragic refusal to heed God’s call.

The same voice speaks today through Scripture. The same call is extended: If you do well, will you not be accepted? But if sin is crouching at your door, do not yield. Master it through the power of obedience, prayer, and truth. For in doing so, you walk the path that leads not to exile and death, but to fellowship with Jehovah and life everlasting.

You May Also Enjoy

How Did the Faithful Die Without Receiving the Promises?

About the Author

EDWARD D. ANDREWS (AS in Criminal Justice, BS in Religion, MA in Biblical Studies, and MDiv in Theology) is CEO and President of Christian Publishing House. He has authored over 220+ books. In addition, Andrews is the Chief Translator of the Updated American Standard Version (UASV).